How well informed are your civic taste buds?
A couple of days ago, my wife suggested we invite some
other families to walk candidate floats in parades this summer. It is a fun way
for younger children to begin to learn about civic processes, and you see that
political candidates are real people, with very diverse personas. BUT…
This year, who should we help? For example, State Rep
Position 1 has four candidates, two of whom we would be inclined to help.
Walking in parades means choosing now. Am I ready to choose? Have these
candidates fully framed their legislative priorities and values? Do they intend
to do so? Or must I choose by sentimental feelings? A candidate first serves
voters by defining his or her self to those voters.
Last year, my daughter Krista and I covered 2013 Whatcom
County school board elections. A large slate of uncontested candidates stayed
home and silent. Competition may spend dollars, but the value far outweighs the
cost. Competitive elections enable informed votes.
Voters grapple with three levels of citizen
responsibility in civic government.
At a foundational level is virtue. We teach our children
to listen well, honor jurisdiction, be grateful, be truthful, be orderly, and
work hard. The list of character goes on. Families, faiths, schools operate on a
cycle of childhood, about fifteen to twenty years.
At a practical level is public policy. Happy people know
issues, jurisdictions, and rules, and work within them. Unhappy peoples ignore
or twist them. Public policy issues generally are a project of 2-5 years.
At the painful level are elections. “Go to” people rise
to the top, and whether by formal ballot or habituated service, are there in
times of need. The wheels of humility and pride grind hard, however, and elected
service has large costs in addition to large benefits. Election seasons are
measured in weeks and months, short and intense.
Easy to ignore, elections are still the hinges of the
future, a time to mix epoxies that shape very long trajectories. Elections are
like weddings—a lot of pomp and fuss, a big party, and a potential big hangover.
Yet, that wedding intiates a fruitful or disastrous family life. So are
elections. The hassles of elections underwrite both big rewards and losses.
This Saturday in Lynden, the 2014 season of local small
town American fairs and parades begins. Who should I vote for? What do these
candidates stand for?
Should I vote for a candidate because I knew them from
childhood?
Should I vote for them because they have raised a good
family?
Should I vote for them because they manage money well?
Should I vote for them because they successfully help
needy people?
Should I vote for them because we need racial diversity
in government office?
Frankly, what is the job description?
Do you buy a dump truck to go to the corner store? Do you
buy a sports car to drive the baseball team to out of town games? Do you buy a
corn chopper to take your RV to the lake?
The volume of local, state and federal business that
elected officials deal with overwhelms the best voter. After the election, the
newly minted public voices begin yelling into the meat grinder of the
bureaucracy. Elected representatives come and go, but bureaucratic apparatchiks
stay long, very long. Elected reps must be very perceptive, focused and quick -- tough and able cookies.
Candidates, please do me a favor. Can you write your own
score card? I don’t mean photo opp flyers.
Can you write an honest scorecard that compares your
priorities to your competition? Sometimes good score cards are very unsettling.
But that can also be very good in the long run. And, how you frame issues on
your score card shows us your underlying assumptions.
1) Prove to me you know what the policy categories of
your civic arena are.
2) Prove to me you know how to coordinate research,
amendment, and writing of law.
3) Prove to me you can improve bureaucracies, especially
vis the public sector unions.
4) Prove to me you have staying power, can ride the
bronco of day to day rules making.
5) Prove to me you can delegate, can build your team, can
affect good policy in caucus.
6) Prove to me you can swim with media sharks, not serve
them, not quarrel with them.
7) Prove to me you are a quick study.
8) Prove to me you are not for sale to the highest
bidder, especially to global corporate or non profit trusts.
9) Prove to me you will not allow outside grant/tax dollars to overwhelm local governance.
10) Prove to me you will reduce the power of shadow government in unelected regional councils and boards
9) Prove to me you will not allow outside grant/tax dollars to overwhelm local governance.
10) Prove to me you will reduce the power of shadow government in unelected regional councils and boards
I could go on. Is it possible to be an informed voter? Is
it possible to be an informed candidate?
One last thing. What might you gain by working for
candidates, by letting the barbecue stay cold for a few more nights than normal
this summer, by helping an election campaign? Why care? Why walk? Why doorbell?
Elections close the loop. What value has virtue if it is
not applied to policy? What value has policy if it does not connect with
people? Elections remind us that we must steer our own boats if we don’t want
to be swamped by the side winds.
You may not know it all, but you can scrape the rust off,
re-oil, and re-engage. Turn off the TV and turn out to some meetings. Ask some
hard questions. It is better
entertainment, and better living.
JK
----------
Nice job John.
ReplyDeleteI think you mean State Rep Pos. 1 has 4 candidates. Position 2 has two candidates and the choice is exceedingly clear. As for Pos 1 - even though the open position became known only weeks ago - a preset worldview helps to frame and prioritize a candidate's values. If you know the candidates well then chances are you know their values and priorities. But always, always ask the tough question. This candidate appreciates opportunities to gain confidence and I accept your challenge to create my own score card.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Luanne, yes, it is position 1, not 2, with four primary candidates. A scorecard comparing key priorities of 4 candidates will need quite small type--maybe? Ha!.
DeleteJohn Kirk